PDA

View Full Version : Is it right to copy a poem from others website forum



meenaram
12-29-2003, 06:34 AM
Hi!
You can debate now whether copying a poem from others website is right or wrong!!!!!!!

sri_gan
12-29-2003, 07:37 PM
Sorna akka,

Side track:::

:lol: Yaara thakureenga? straighta avangakitta sollirunga...

Main Track:::

I will write only my own poems.

As long as you mention the original poet name in the forums I think it is sufficient.

It is really bad to copy one's poem and name it for yourself 'cause if the original poet sees it, he/she would feel like hurted.

meenaram
12-30-2003, 06:59 AM
Sorna akka,

Side track:::

:lol: Yaara thakureenga? straighta avangakitta sollirunga...

Main Track:::

I will write only my own poems.

As long as you mention the original poet name in the forums I think it is sufficient.

It is really bad to copy one's poem and name it for yourself 'cause if the original poet sees it, he/she would feel like hurted.sri-thambi i will tell at the last y i am making this poll. FYI I am absolutely zero in poem writings!!!!!!!!!!!! lol

Happy holidays!

sri_gan
12-30-2003, 12:00 PM
FYI I am absolutely zero in poem writings!!!!!!!!!!!!


Sorna akka,

:lol: Athu enakku eppaiyo theriyum.

sabeshan
12-30-2003, 01:18 PM
Is it right to copy a poem from others website forum

As srigan says, it is wrong to copy a poem from some other website and
post it here as one's own but it is also wrong to copy it even after acknowledging
the source because such compilers (read copiers) get good stuff from every website
and make our website a collection of good articles which gives us an unfair edge
over other websites where such practices are not followed.

silican
12-30-2003, 04:11 PM
I cnt completely agree with sabeshan's aguement. When u give credit to the poet and provide the source inyour posting, I dont think theres anything wrong. Afterall, if someone likes the poem/poet's talent, they might go to that particular website. So it is sort an advt to tht poet and tht website.

Silicab

sWEEtmICHe
12-30-2003, 05:14 PM
oops!!!........sWEEtmICHe..... ....."Princess of Geetham"
has arrived...enna poem ....aaaaaaa en aachi

suryalover
12-30-2003, 05:28 PM
In my view after coming to Internet lot of issues are like this..
Its nothing wrong in mentioning the source as it gives credit to the work that the author has done. So by mentioning the author its nothing wrong in my opinion...

meenaram
12-30-2003, 05:35 PM
In my view after coming to Internet lot of issues are like this..
Its nothing wrong in mentioning the source as it gives credit to the work that the author has done. So by mentioning the author its nothing wrong in my opinion...suryalover, sabeshan and silican,
In some sites people are not mentioning the orginal authors. when the real authors come to know this i know their feelings. so what do u say for this!

sofiadorathy
01-05-2004, 09:23 AM
hello meenaram ur debate is really cool....i have voted for No....because there is nothing wrong in copying a poem from other websites to a particular website....but the fact is the author shoud post the name of the author.....thats the must.....meethi arguements later argue pannuren....waiting for opponents answers....

Be Happy.....

sWEEtmICHe
01-05-2004, 01:24 PM
hey meena thanks for the thread .......... :b:
i have been affected so much .....
seen ma poems in many websites.....
claiming to be theirs,
even authors name written.... {but removed.}
exact poem...with pix...
i know a few of geetham members are aware.....
they knew that, belongs to sWEEtmIChe's why the silence.........?
they pretend nothing happens .....where the justice ????????????
ADMIN.....PLZ take note!!.......any solution.........?
I know that u are not aware......,
b'cuz i didn't brought up this issue!! so far in this forum..
wot is ur opinion... hope fair reply!!
sad :sm18:

sofiadorathy
01-10-2004, 08:47 AM
hey meena thanks for the thread .......... :b:
i have been affected so much .....
seen ma poems in many websites.....
claiming to be theirs,
even authors name written.... {but removed.}
exact poem...with pix...
i know a few of geetham members are aware.....
they knew that, belongs to sWEEtmIChe's why the silence.........?
they pretend nothing happens .....where the justice ????????????
ADMIN.....PLZ take note!!.......any solution.........?
I know that u are not aware......,
b'cuz i didn't brought up this issue!! so far in this forum..
wot is ur opinion... hope fair reply!!
sad :sm18:




better give a pm to admin ..... and give the names of the author who posted ur poems....that will be gud or give a pm to admin....or to poem section moderators...
that will be gud....or give the names here itself...

Be Happy....

sWEEtmICHe
01-11-2004, 12:16 PM
sofia.....wot pm to Admin .....oops!!
well how.....?
anyway......I am frightened.....
I can but to ur admin......!!!
well i don't know him well.....,
wot will he think abt this matter
will i get any solution?
thanks yaar..... :wink:

sofiadorathy
01-11-2004, 12:33 PM
sofia.....wot pm to Admin .....oops!!
well how.....?
anyway......I am frightened.....
I can but to ur admin......!!!
well i don't know him well.....,
wot will he think abt this matter
will i get any solution?
thanks yaar..... :wink:


sweetmiche neeenga vilayaatukku pesureengala illa serious-aa pesureeengalaa???? neenga sollurathaala Admin enna panna poraaaru ungala...he will be so kind...so dont worry yaar....juzz explain him...otherwise take the second option of me and say the names over here...none will happen...u have the rights here....so dunt worry

Be Happy....

sofiadorathy
01-11-2004, 12:36 PM
swwetmiche dunt worry....i have send a pm to Admin regarding this......U 2 give him a pm...

Be Happy....

sWEEtmICHe
01-11-2004, 01:06 PM
hey sofia......
thanks yaar!!
but nope..ur admin.....aaaaaa
no daaaaaaa ...
i am feeling funny..plzzzz

sofiadorathy
01-11-2004, 01:08 PM
ok have u got any reply from him???????pls inform me...i will take further steps...lol

Be Happy...

sWEEtmICHe
01-11-2004, 01:13 PM
i wanna bring it to light but alot of ppl will be affected
at the same time.....i felt like a fool......,
i breathe ma poems.....and someone is enjoying{claiming}
and getting all names.......not fair yaar.... :cry:

sWEEtmICHe
01-11-2004, 09:56 PM
hey fRIENDs
wot u all think abot sofia's idea ?
For me I think is great...
bcuz she gave 2 option..
plz write ur comments....
thank u ...sofia :wink:
anyway no reply from ur Admin.......oops!!
still waiting..wot he gonna say...aaaaaaaaaaaaaaaa
advance thanks.. thanks aDMIn... :Ksp:

sofiadorathy
01-12-2004, 04:07 AM
ok i think none will give comments here....but juzz give the names here and their poems....then we shall make some ideas about that....ok????? dunt worry

Be Happy.......

vennai1
01-12-2004, 08:44 AM
well..yes.. we can debate on this over and over again !


but technically... the answer and the laws are clear..

copying/linking is allowed with proper acknowlegdement unless

the author/website does not approve of even that! :b:


PS: sweetmiche.. if someone is stealing your poems...just contact

that particular website's admin !

sWEEtmICHe
01-12-2004, 12:29 PM
hey sofia..thanks!!
well i am feeling bad....,
wanted justice but turn down...by the website Admin!!
geetham responded......,
he is willing to take action ,if the poems are in this website!!
and stolen by geetham's members...
well it is by them but was put in another site...,
as vennai1 said,bring to the attention of the web admin.....,
that was wot geetham Admin also says...
well poem is not a cut and paste.....
it is all ma feelings put up in words...,almost all they took
and are claiming theirs....well i don't know...
thanks to sofia..been so bold and so sWEEt ,
geetham been so kind and helpful
vennai1 been so caring and touching!!
sad sWEEt

sWEEtmICHe
01-12-2004, 01:00 PM
vennai1 .....10q
and meenaram. ...
thanks for the post so swEEt of u
and all the caring ppls of geetham's family,
i am lucky to be here with u all and sharing :cry:

sri_gan
01-12-2004, 01:30 PM
vennai1 .....10q
and meenaram. ...
thanks for the post so swEEt of u
and all the caring ppls of geetham's family,
i am lucky to be here with u all and sharing :cry:

sweetmiche,

Topic a arambichuttu ippa innathu aluthukinnu irruke athan ellarum reply podurangala...

Naan vera yaarium per solli kuppida matten nu vakku koduthuten...

:lol: enna thirudan kadalai vandiya inga thalikittu varalainu ore varuthama? pm annuppu kandippa kadalai vandi inga varum.

sWEEtmICHe
01-12-2004, 04:03 PM
sweetmiche,
Topic a arambichuttu ippa innathu aluthukinnu irruke athan ellarum reply podurangala...
Naan vera yaarium per solli kuppida matten nu vakku koduthuten...
:lol: enna thirudan kadalai vandiya inga thalikittu varalainu ore varuthama? pm annuppu kandippa kadalai vandi inga varum.
sri......hehe
varutham illai...thirudan romba busy aaaaaa...,
kadalai vandi ippa vara site irrukaaaaaaaa ...

Now every star is asking me
Where have u been my dear moon?
Plz come and shine
We can't hold too long…
The sky is still at dark
Oh heart plse change her
Every word of them
Had tormented her so much
And now she is carried away
by crying ........
Thinking hurting herself
No one can win her heart of poem
But she felt the pain and shame
For the them to say such words

Why am I hiding……
My light is not that bright
C'mon mICHe make it shine
says sri .....
sorry ma fRIENd
I fight for ma moves
Ma approach have failed
Feeling pain…. weeping....
thanks for ur fine words sri....
Words that reflect the most inner feelings of your heart.
And that's exactly what u offer: Words of Love
Moon is waiting for u in the verge to shine...now! :Ksp: :Ksp: :Ksp:

sofiadorathy
01-12-2004, 09:33 PM
sweetmiche neeenga innum enakku answer pannave illaye.... did admin replied u???/

Be Happy...

sabeshan
01-13-2004, 02:02 AM
hey sweetmiche... one small kustin.... neenga LKG la 'y' endra oru letter a padichchade illaya??? :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

enga pathalum 'my' kku badhila 'ma ma' nnu aadu maari pesareengale... pls don take seriously... joke adikkanum nu thonichu adhan sonnen... no offense meant...

vennai1
01-13-2004, 02:07 AM
sebastian...

sweet miche got double promotion from pre-kg to ukg...so she dint go to lkg...

athaan ... nee feel aavaathey... ;) ;)

sabeshan
01-13-2004, 02:14 AM
Hi bro Victor,

Welcome back to Geetham family after a loooooooooooong time....

sri_gan
01-13-2004, 02:36 AM
Sabeshan,

Nallikka ma best friend unna uruga vaikala... ma best friend peru sWeet mICHE illa ma solliten...

sWEEtmICHe
01-14-2004, 07:29 PM
sweetmiche neeenga innum enakku answer pannave illaye.... did admin replied u???/
Be Happy...


hey sofia ..Admin's reply :wink:


hey sofia..thanks!!
well i am feeling bad....,
wanted justice but turn down...by the website Admin!!
geetham responded......,
he is willing to take action ,if the poems are in this website!!
and stolen by geetham's members...
well it is by them but was put in another site...,
as vennai1 said,bring to the attention of the web admin.....,
that was wot geetham Admin also says...
:cry:

sWEEtmICHe
01-14-2004, 07:35 PM
hey sweetmiche... one small kustin.... neenga LKG la 'y' endra oru letter a padichchade illaya??? :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol: :lol:

enga pathalum 'my' kku badhila 'ma ma' nnu aadu maari pesareengale... pls don take seriously... joke adikkanum nu thonichu adhan sonnen... no offense meant...
hey sabeshan.......lols ..hehe
I used ma..... ma fav yaar..
infected by webvirus.....thats why ..maaaaaaaa ..UKG ..

sWEEtmICHe
01-14-2004, 07:42 PM
sebastian...

sweet miche got double promotion from pre-kg to ukg...so she dint go to lkg...

athaan ... nee feel aavaathey... ;) ;)


haaaaaaaaaa eeee..
thanks for ur all the kg......lols... :ahha:
thanks again yaar chellam.....oops!! :Ksp:
sebastian......appadiya ....hehe
f

sWEEtmICHe
01-14-2004, 08:01 PM
Sabeshan,

Nallikka ma best friend unna uruga vaikala... ma best friend peru sWeet mICHE illa ma solliten...
sri appadiya .....
sebastian enna ....mudiyuma ?.
cone ice cream aa uruga vaikavaaaaaaaaa ?

butterfly
01-14-2004, 08:12 PM
meenaram wrote,


Hi!
You can debate now whether copying a poem from others website is right or wrong!!!!!!!

its wrong meena...unless one shud take their permission or atleast write their name while posting their poems...but wrong to claim someone else's poems as theirs

Miche wrote,


hey meena thanks for the thread ..........
i have been affected so much .....
seen ma poems in many websites.....
claiming to be theirs,
even authors name written.... {but removed.}
exact poem...with pix...
i know a few of geetham members are aware.....
they knew that, belongs to sWEEtmIChe's why the silence.........?
they pretend nothing happens .....where the justice ????????????
ADMIN.....PLZ take note!!.......any solution.........?
I know that u are not aware......,
b'cuz i didn't brought up this issue!! so far in this forum..
wot is ur opinion... hope fair reply!!
sad


Miche,
If u know the person doing it...approach them directly...if they dont want to admit bring it to open forum....I dunno how much our administrator can help u on this...cos he may not have access to find out who is posting ur poems in their names in other websites...

sWEEtmICHe
01-18-2004, 01:01 AM
meenaram wrote,


Hi!
You can debate now whether copying a poem from others website is right or wrong!!!!!!!

its wrong meena...unless one shud take their permission or atleast write their name while posting their poems...but wrong to claim someone else's poems as theirs

Miche wrote,


hey meena thanks for the thread ..........
i have been affected so much .....
seen ma poems in many websites.....
claiming to be theirs,
even authors name written.... {but removed.}
exact poem...with pix...
i know a few of geetham members are aware.....
they knew that, belongs to sWEEtmIChe's why the silence.........?
they pretend nothing happens .....where the justice ????????????
ADMIN.....PLZ take note!!.......any solution.........?
I know that u are not aware......,
b'cuz i didn't brought up this issue!! so far in this forum..
wot is ur opinion... hope fair reply!!
sad


Miche,
If u know the person doing it...approach them directly...if they dont want to admit bring it to open forum....I dunno how much our administrator can help u on this...cos he may not have access to find out who is posting ur poems in their names in other websites...

hey butterfly,
thanks and ur advise sounds good,
as wot all our geetham's says go ahead bring them to light!!
Is not that easy butterfly,
i know that person is in this forum but in different name
as he owes the website.....,
i felt bad cuz i was turn down......
like no r/ts for ma own poem
u can take but don't claim is yours..
well geetham Admin...
also been nice and thought,willingly to take action
sad
mICHe

Shy
01-18-2004, 03:38 AM
Thats sad.. to know that someone is claiming our piece of work... Thats right miche.. its hard to bring someone with this responsibility to light.. they should have known better.. but dont worry.. admin has said he will take care right... sure he will do something.. no worry at all...

U please continue showering us with ur cute poems whenevr u get a chance...

Be cheerful miche

Shy

sWEEtmICHe
01-25-2004, 02:39 PM
Thats sad.. to know that someone is claiming our piece of work... Thats right miche.. its hard to bring someone with this responsibility to light.. they should have known better.. but dont worry.. admin has said he will take care right... sure he will do something.. no worry at all...

U please continue showering us with ur cute poems whenevr u get a chance...

Be cheerful miche

Shy

thanks yaar
so sweet and well poured!! :wink:

Shy
01-25-2004, 06:08 PM
mm.. Innum nalla super poems poodungo okvaa? dont worry.. sure will admin take care..:)

Shy

meenaram
01-29-2004, 04:21 PM
Sorna akka,

Side track:::

:lol: Yaara thakureenga? straighta avangakitta sollirunga...

Main Track:::

I will write only my own poems.

As long as you mention the original poet name in the forums I think it is sufficient.

It is really bad to copy one's poem and name it for yourself 'cause if the original poet sees it, he/she would feel like hurted.sri-thambi i will tell at the last y i am making this poll. FYI I am absolutely zero in poem writings!!!!!!!!!!!! lol

Happy holidays!

main track::
sri-thambi sweetiee kaga thaan entha threada post pannen.

side track:
sorry sri...really busy with work couldn't upload the c.cousin's songs. i will do it this sunday +vely. KTS akka

sWEEtmICHe
01-31-2004, 10:54 AM
thanks meena kutty.. :b:
btw i am happy to see all the comments and views abt the interest they took to help me.and special thanks goes to sri ..sofia...shy.....butterfly ..vennia1. .. kutty meena and all ma sWEEt fRIENDs ..and ma .. chella fREINd n Admin..........oops!!

sWEEtmICHe
03-27-2005, 04:33 PM
`i am bring another issue here ..,
hope all can welcome !! .......`

bbabab2004
03-28-2005, 10:59 PM
sweet admin,
it is wrong to copy. it is cheating. please donot copy. even i can cut and copy from website to post here. what is the use ??????

valluvan
03-28-2005, 11:14 PM
sweet admin,
it is wrong to copy. it is cheating. please donot copy. even i can cut and copy from website to post here. what is the use ??????



Yeap. I agree that copying one's stuff is unfair. But I feel that we can quote the poem along with author's name. If that is not the case, then how are we quoting Vairamuthu, Kannadaasan and Vaali's quotes in our forum. Is it wrong? When any stuffs come in to public, then we can't stop them handled by others though we have the copy rights. Isn't it?

If I see something in CNN or BBC or Kumudham, I am sharing it and discussing it. Is it wrong?

coolian
03-28-2005, 11:57 PM
Absolutely nothing wrong in using someone else's literary work (with credits, of course!) unless that person has explicitly stated that that should not be done. And one thing to note though - if anyone publishes anything on the 'net, there is a pretty high chance that it will, at sometime, be ripped off by some random dude. That's akin to leaving money outside, for all to see and take. Fact is, there are a lot of idiots out there, so there's no way to 'safeguard' things (especially intangible ones!) that belong to you, on the internet. Gotta live with it :-(.

nadaarun
04-05-2005, 12:00 PM
This is a BIT funny TOPIC i would like to say...........

According to the INTERNET PRVICAY ACT

Copying/Hotlinking without Permission or Copyrights are straight away illegal

and COPYING A POEM or LYRICS and stating its done by them is just SO EXTRA...
ITS ALRIGHT THEY CAN COPY IT AND POST IN THIER SITES but with AUTHOR NAME and the SOURCE where they got it FROM......
People who are doing this Should be BANNED from all sites.. Admins Should Take Note On This....Not ONly ADMIN of this SITE but all the ADMINS of TAMILSITES ON THE NET..

Please Take Note: Nothing Can Prevent People COPYING except thier own MIND. even if we impose JAVA Scripts to STOP COPY PROTECT or RIGHT CLICK PROHIBITING they can just TYPE the same POEM in mins...{or otherways to do which i wont mention hehehe}

I dont know about OTHERS but I KNOW HOW MUCH AKKA{Miche} IS HURT BY THIS STUPID PEOPLE COPYING HER WORK and PUTTING THIER NAMES. So probably all oders would feel de Same...

I would be Really Happy If no ONE COPIES POEMS or LYRICS and put THIER NAMES>...thankyou